Thursday, July 1, 2010

Let us Agree to Disagree :)

Let us Agree to Disagree before I go on

I don’t really read marathi literature anymore – but if I say this aloud amongst my friends there will be an uproar I will be instantly labeled a snobbish reader- as the reason for the downfall of our maay marathi –
But I don’t Agree ----
I read a lot and on a variety of subjects from pulp fiction to philosophy to poetry to religion to archie comics---- Shakespeare to Chetan Bhagat - I see a lot of films nearly one a day and very very rarely do I need to see the same film twice- I read more books than I re view films-
So basically I have touched so many subjects –some I have gone to depths some I have just skipped through – I can be called a well read person

All this introduction so that my reviews are taken a tad more seriously than they would be other wise......
Well it seems that good old approval crises still rears its not so pretty head once in a while.....

Well the point of the matter is I don’t really like Chetan Bhagat’s Writing- and was met with instant reproval- I did not really get to support my statement –
I don’t really like CB’s work – I find it for want of a better word mediocre –
He does write simple to the point short books that tell stories that millions of Indian youth enjoy reading BUT He is not a good writer in the literary sense. He is no Vikram Seth or Arundhati Roy.I see no reason to read a piece of mediocre work and praise it . I see no reason to praise any mediocrity at all

It is not that I am against CB I am against Sandip khare and Salil Kulkarni too
Another explosive discussion waiting to happen-
(Sandip khare is a marathi poet and lyricist currently a hot favourite like CB in the 25 something age group.Salil Kulkarni of the sa Re ga ma fameJ a music director again ahot favourite in the same age group –)
An age group that is barely literate in my books- that is - they are engineers and professionals but they have not read anything beyond the scope of their exams- their exposure to classics is basically the cartoon films made on the books- who think “Sidney Sheldon” is a classic- and Kailas Kher is a sufi singer
Let me say this again I am not against any of the People I mentioned above – I am against the mediocre work that is being praised- the mediocrity of a creative piece has to noticed –accepted and improved upon—
To recognize mediocrity when it is shoved in your face and to be able to reject it – we must explore that what is the best-
When the young praise Khare as pratiGADIMA(gadima reincarnate) - the valmiki of marathi literature who wrote the Geet Ramayan –that got translated in 9 indian languages- a legendary poet, lyricist, playwright, script-writer, dialogue writer, actor, novelist… I wish these worthy fans would read at least one work of GADIMA and choke on their words of praise for the mediocre…

Do read this article “A” literature for hundred rupees .


2 comments:

  1. Isn't it too bad the way your literature choices are made to reflect on you politically? Not liking a particular writer's style is such a personal choice and doesn't make one snobbish! (Within my area I get a lot of flak for not liking Harry Potter much!)

    ReplyDelete
  2. sorry for the late acknowledgement Aamba ... dumb me did not notice the comment:)
    is it so hard to accept unity in diversity :) a line we have had pushed down our throats all our literate lifes makes me think we shold have digested it and learnt to live with the differnces :)

    ReplyDelete